Staten Island Estate Planning and Probate

Estate Planning Attorneys in Staten Island

Estate Planning in New York Is About Control—Not Just Assets

Estate planning is not just about what happens after you pass away. It is about maintaining control over your finances, your healthcare decisions, and your family’s future—while you are alive and after you are gone.

Without a plan, New York law—not your wishes—determines how your assets are distributed, who makes decisions for you, and how long your family may be tied up in court.

At Angiuli & Gentile, LLP, we have helped Staten Island families protect what they have built since 1985, creating clear, legally sound estate plans tailored to each client’s life and goals.

What Happens If You Die Without a Will in New York

If you pass away without a will, your estate is distributed under New York’s intestacy law (EPTL §4-1.1).

For example:

  • If you have a spouse and children, your spouse receives $50,000 plus half of the remaining estate, with the balance going to your children
  • If you have a spouse and no children, your spouse receives everything

These rules are rigid. They do not account for blended families, stepchildren, or personal intentions.

This is one of the most common—and preventable—sources of family conflict.

The New York Estate Tax “Cliff”

New York’s estate tax system creates a significant planning issue.

The 2026 exemption is approximately $7.35 million per individual.

However:

If your estate exceeds the exemption by more than 5%, you lose the exemption entirely, and the full estate becomes taxable.

This “cliff” can result in substantial, unexpected tax liability.

For many families, proper planning is not about avoiding taxes altogether—it is about avoiding unnecessary ones.

Why Estate Planning Matters for Every Adult

Estate planning is not just for high-net-worth individuals.

If you:

  • Own a home
  • Have children
  • Want to control medical decisions
  • Want to avoid delays and court involvement

then estate planning is essential.

Without it, the court decides:

  • Who inherits your assets
  • Who cares for your children
  • Who manages your finances if you are incapacitated
  • How long your family waits for access to your estate

Wills: The Foundation of Your Plan

A will allows you to:

  • Direct how your assets are distributed
  • Name an executor to manage your estate
  • Appoint guardians for minor children
  • Provide instructions for personal property and specific bequests

Without a valid will, your estate must go through probate and be distributed according to state law.

Trusts: Avoid Probate and Protect Your Assets

Trusts offer greater flexibility, control, and privacy than wills alone.

We assist clients in establishing:

  • Revocable Living Trusts to avoid probate and maintain control during life
  • Irrevocable Trusts to protect assets from taxes, creditors, or long-term care exposure
  • Special Needs Trusts to provide for loved ones without affecting benefits
  • Testamentary Trusts to protect minors or vulnerable beneficiaries

A properly structured trust can significantly reduce court involvement and delay.

Probate in Staten Island: What Families Should Expect

Probate is handled through Surrogate’s Court.

For Staten Island residents:

  • Richmond County Surrogate’s Court is located at 18 Richmond Terrace

Typical probate timelines:

  • Simple estates: 7–12 months
  • Average estates: 12–18 months
  • Complex or contested matters: 2+ years

In addition to time, there are also filing fees under SCPA §2402, which increase based on estate value.

For many families, avoiding probate through proper planning is a priority.

Powers of Attorney and Health Care Proxies

Estate planning also protects you during your lifetime.

A Durable Power of Attorney allows someone to manage your financial affairs if you become incapacitated.

A Health Care Proxy allows someone to make medical decisions on your behalf.

A Living Will outlines your preferences for life-sustaining treatment.

Without these documents, your family may need to seek court-appointed guardianship.

Guardianship in New York

When no planning is in place, guardianship proceedings may be required.

We assist with:

  • Article 81 guardianship (incapacitated adults)
  • Article 17-A guardianship (individuals with developmental disabilities)

These proceedings require court petitions and judicial approval and can be time-consuming and emotionally difficult.

Proper planning can often avoid them entirely.

Estate Administration and Probate Disputes

We assist clients with all aspects of estate administration, including:

  • Filing wills with Surrogate’s Court
  • Identifying and distributing assets
  • Handling debts and tax obligations
  • Resolving disputes among beneficiaries
  • Representing clients in will contests or fiduciary disputes

These matters require both legal precision and sensitivity to family dynamics.

Building an Estate Plan That Reflects Your Life

No two estate plans are the same.

We work closely with clients to:

  • Understand family structure and priorities
  • Identify potential risks and tax exposure
  • Design a plan that evolves over time

Estate planning is not a one-time event. It is an ongoing process.
This site also includes a page on the personal affairs and estate planning organizer, a centralized set of documents that brings together financial, health care, legal, and final-wishes information.

What to Expect When You Get Started

  1. Initial consultation to understand your goals
  2. Review of assets and family structure
  3. Development of a customized plan
  4. Drafting and execution of documents
  5. Ongoing updates as your life changes

Probate in Richmond County Surrogate’s Court, Step by Step

Probate begins by filing the original will, a death certificate, and a probate petition in the Surrogate’s Court of the county where the decedent lived, for Staten Island families, Richmond County. The decedent’s distributees (the relatives who would inherit if there were no will) must receive notice through waivers or a citation, because they hold the right to challenge the will. If no one objects and the will was properly executed, the court issues a decree and Letters Testamentary to the named executor, the document banks and brokers require before releasing anything.

The executor then marshals assets, has them valued as of death, pays debts and administration expenses, and manages the estate’s tax filings. Creditors have seven months from the issuance of letters to present claims, and a prudent executor does not make final distributions before that window and the tax picture are clear. The estate closes with distributions to beneficiaries and, depending on the will and the estate’s size, a formal or informal accounting. Most straightforward estates complete probate administration in roughly a year; contested or tax-heavy estates run longer. Executors routinely discover that the decedent’s planning choices, or their absence, set the timetable: our probate and estate administration practice starts with that reality and works backward.

The New York Estate Tax “Cliff”: Why the Exemption Is Not the Whole Story

New York taxes estates that the federal government ignores. The state exemption was $7.16 million for 2025 and adjusts periodically, far below the federal exemption. Worse, New York’s exemption phases out in a way no other state’s does: tax professionals call it the cliff. If a taxable estate exceeds the exemption by more than 5 percent, the exemption disappears entirely and New York taxes the estate from the first dollar, so a modest amount of appreciation near death can produce a disproportionate tax bill.

Planning around the cliff is a specialty of its own: credit-shelter and disclaimer trusts that capture a first spouse’s exemption, lifetime gifting programs (New York has no gift tax of its own, though the rules on gifts made near death have changed in recent years and need current advice), charitable bequests that trim the taxable estate at the margin, and, for couples near the line, wills drafted so the executor can choose among formulas after death when the numbers are known. Staten Island real estate alone puts more estates near the New York line than families expect, once the house, retirement accounts, and insurance are added up. For a loved one with disabilities, a trust attorney in Staten Island can set up a supplemental needs trust that protects their benefits.

Second Marriages and Blended Families: The Documents That Prevent Fights

The default rules are not designed for blended families, and the conflicts are predictable. A will that leaves everything to a new spouse “trusting” them to provide for the first family usually results in the first family receiving nothing, lawfully. New York’s elective-share statute (EPTL 5-1.1) guarantees a surviving spouse the greater of $50,000 or one-third of the net estate against most attempts to disinherit, and beneficiary designations on retirement accounts, life insurance, and transfer-on-death accounts pass outside the will entirely, which is where many plans silently fail.

Blended-family planning aligns all of it: wills or trusts that provide for the spouse during life while preserving the remainder for the decedent’s own children, beneficiary forms checked against the documents, joint titles reviewed (joint property passes to the survivor regardless of the will), and, where appropriate, no-contest clauses, which New York enforces within limits under EPTL 3-3.5. The conversation is delicate and the paperwork is not, which is precisely why it should happen with counsel while everyone is healthy and relations are warm.

Digital Assets: The Accounts Your Will Does Not Mention

A modern estate includes assets no safe deposit box ever held: email and cloud photo archives, banking and brokerage logins, cryptocurrency wallets, domain names, loyalty balances, and monetized social accounts. New York addressed fiduciary access in 2016 by adopting Article 13-A of the EPTL (its version of the Revised Uniform Fiduciary Access to Digital Assets Act), which lets users direct disclosure through a service’s own online tool or through their will, trust, or power of attorney, and sets the rules custodians must follow when a fiduciary requests access.

The statute does not rescue poor record-keeping. An executor cannot distribute or even find what the family cannot identify, and cryptocurrency held without accessible keys is simply lost. Every estate plan should now include a maintained inventory of digital accounts and access instructions, stored securely and referenced in the plan documents. The conversation takes twenty minutes; reconstructing a digital estate without it can take the better part of the administration.

Guardianship Nominations: The Most Important Clause for Young Parents

For parents of minor children, the most consequential provision in a will is not financial: it is the nomination of a guardian of the person and of the property for the children if both parents die. Under SCPA Article 17, the Surrogate’s Court appoints guardians, but it gives controlling weight to the parents’ nomination in the will, which is how parents rather than relatives-by-default choose who raises their children. The same planning should address money: a child’s inheritance held in a trust under the will, with staggered distributions, rather than paid outright at 18.

Parents should also name contingent guardians (the first choice may be unable to serve years later) and tell the nominees they have been chosen. A guardianship nomination that surprises its nominee at the reading of the will is a plan half-made. These provisions cost nothing extra in the drafting and are the reason many young families make wills at all.

Contact a Staten Island Estate Planning Attorney

Estate planning is your opportunity to protect your family, preserve your assets, and make your wishes clear.

At Angiuli & Gentile, LLP, we provide experienced, practical guidance to help you plan with confidence.

Schedule a private consultation today.

Frequently Asked Questions About Estate Planning and Probate in New York

Estate planning in New York runs through the Surrogate’s Court and a set of statutes that punish improvisation: unsigned documents, outdated forms, and assets titled the wrong way. The answers below explain how planning and probate actually work in New York. They are general information, not advice about a specific estate.

What happens if I die without a will in New York?

Your estate passes by intestacy under EPTL 4-1.1, in a fixed order the statute chooses, not you. If you are survived by a spouse and children, your spouse takes the first $50,000 plus one-half of the remainder, and your children share the rest, including minor children outright at 18 through a guardianship. With a spouse and no children, everything goes to your spouse; with children and no spouse, everything goes to your children; more distant relatives follow in a defined sequence, and if no statutory relatives exist, the estate escheats to the State of New York.

Intestacy also means the Surrogate’s Court appoints an administrator in a statutory priority order, which may not be the person you would have chosen, and no provision can be made for stepchildren, unmarried partners, friends, or charities, none of whom inherit under the statute. A will is the only instrument that lets you direct otherwise.

Sources: EPTL 4-1.1, intestate distribution (New York State Senate); Intestacy (Cornell Law Institute)

How long does probate take in New York?

Obtaining Letters Testamentary in an uncontested case can take a matter of weeks to a few months once the petition is filed, depending on how quickly waivers are collected and the court’s calendar. Administering the estate takes longer: creditors have seven months from the issuance of letters to present claims, assets must be valued and sometimes sold, and estate tax returns, where required, run on their own deadlines. A straightforward estate typically wraps up in about a year.

The delays that stretch estates to two years and beyond are objections and will contests, missing or estranged distributees who must be located and served, real estate that must be sold, and tax audits. Good planning compresses the timeline materially: an original, properly executed will with witness affidavits, assets inventoried in advance, and beneficiaries who know what to expect.

Sources: Probate (Cornell Law Institute); EPTL 4-1.1, intestate distribution (New York State Senate)

What does an executor do, and what are they paid?

The executor is the estate’s fiduciary: they collect and value assets, give notice to creditors, pay debts, taxes, and administration expenses, defend or settle claims against the estate, and distribute what remains according to the will, accounting to the beneficiaries for every step. It is real work with personal liability for mistakes, which is why executors are entitled to statutory commissions unless the will provides otherwise.

Under SCPA 2307, commissions run on a sliding scale of the value received and paid out: 5 percent of the first $100,000, 4 percent of the next $200,000, 3 percent of the next $700,000, 2.5 percent of the next $4 million, and 2 percent above that. Commissions are income to the executor. Naming someone organized, trustworthy, and able to work with the beneficiaries matters more than naming the eldest child by default, and naming a successor executor is essential.

Sources: Probate (Cornell Law Institute); Will (Cornell Law Institute)

What is a small estate, or voluntary administration, in New York?

SCPA Article 13 offers a simplified procedure, voluntary administration, for estates whose personal property (not counting real estate) is worth $50,000 or less. Instead of full probate or administration, a voluntary administrator (usually the closest distributee or the will’s nominee) files a short affidavit and receives a certificate for each asset to be collected, which banks accept to release accounts. The procedure fits the common case of a modest bank account and personal effects.

Real property cannot be transferred through voluntary administration in the ordinary way, and estates above the threshold, or with disputes among distributees, need full proceedings. Choosing the wrong track wastes months, so the first step in any estate is an inventory: what did the decedent own, how is it titled, and what does each asset require to move it to the beneficiaries?

Sources: Probate (Cornell Law Institute); EPTL 4-1.1, intestate distribution (New York State Senate)

Does a revocable living trust avoid probate in New York?

Yes, for the assets actually transferred into it. A revocable trust holds title to your house, accounts, and other assets during your life, with you as trustee and beneficiary; at death, the successor trustee distributes or holds the assets under the trust’s terms without Surrogate’s Court proceedings. The qualifier matters: assets never transferred into the trust (an unfunded trust) still pass through probate, which is why a pour-over will accompanies the trust as a backstop.

Trusts also buy privacy (a will becomes public in probate; a trust does not), continuity if you become incapacitated, and smoother handling of out-of-state property, which otherwise requires an ancillary probate in that state. They do not, by themselves, reduce estate taxes or protect assets from the Medicaid lookback; revocable trust assets remain fully countable and taxable, a distinction sellers of trust packages blur and families should not.

Sources: Trust (Cornell Law Institute); Will (Cornell Law Institute)

How does the New York estate tax cliff work?

New York allows an exemption from its estate tax ($7.16 million for decedents in 2025, adjusted periodically). Unlike the federal system, however, New York phases the exemption out aggressively: estates valued between 100 and 105 percent of the exemption lose it gradually, and an estate more than 5 percent over the exemption loses it completely, so the entire estate is taxed from the first dollar. A relatively small excess can therefore trigger a tax bill vastly larger than the excess itself.

The cliff makes post-death flexibility valuable: wills for married couples are often drafted with credit-shelter or disclaimer options so the executor can fine-tune how much passes under each spouse’s exemption once values are known. Lifetime gifts, charitable planning, and life-insurance structuring are the other levers. Anyone whose net worth, house included, is anywhere near the exemption should have the arithmetic run, because the cliff is unforgiving of approximations.

Sources: EPTL 5-1.1, spousal elective share (New York State Senate); Trust (Cornell Law Institute)

What is the difference between a health care proxy and a living will?

A health care proxy (Public Health Law Article 29-C) names an agent to make medical decisions for you when you cannot make them yourself. It is the single most important incapacity document in New York, because without an agent, decisions default to the Family Health Care Decisions Act’s surrogate list and its limits. A living will is different: it is a statement of your wishes about life-sustaining treatment in defined end-of-life circumstances, which New York courts honor as evidence of those wishes, although New York has no living-will statute as such.

Used together, the proxy supplies the decision-maker and the living will supplies the guidance that makes the agent’s decisions faithful, and less agonizing. A MOLST form, completed with a physician, converts wishes into medical orders for seriously ill patients. Every adult should execute a proxy; it costs almost nothing and prevents the most painful court proceeding in this field, an Article 81 guardianship filed by a family that cannot agree.

Sources: Living will (Cornell Law Institute); Power of attorney (Cornell Law Institute)

What should I know about New York’s power of attorney?

New York overhauled its statutory power of attorney in 2021 to simplify execution and force third-party acceptance. The principal signs before a notary and two witnesses (the notary may serve as one witness), and banks and other institutions must accept a valid statutory form within set timeframes or state their objection, with liability for unreasonable refusal. The agent’s authority, including any authority to make gifts or change beneficiaries, is set out in the document’s modifications section; the old separate Statutory Gifts Rider no longer exists.

A power of attorney is the cheapest incapacity insurance available and the most commonly missing: without one, paying a parent’s bills or selling their home after a stroke requires an Article 81 guardianship proceeding. Old forms signed under prior law generally remain valid if properly executed at the time, but the 2021 changes improved them enough that refreshing an aging POA is usually worthwhile.

Sources: General Obligations Law 5-1501, powers of attorney (New York State Senate); Power of attorney (Cornell Law Institute)

Can a will be contested in New York?

Yes. After a will is offered for probate, interested persons may file objections on grounds that it was not properly executed (EPTL 3-2.1 requires signature and two witnesses), that the decedent lacked testamentary capacity, or that it was the product of undue influence or fraud. Before deciding, an objectant can examine the will’s drafting attorney and witnesses under SCPA 1404, a discovery step that often determines whether a contest is filed at all.

Most wills are admitted without a fight, and contests are expensive and uncertain for the challenger, who generally must be a distributee who would do better without the will. Prevention is standard practice: proper execution formalities, contemporaneous witness affidavits, capacity documented where there is any question, and no-contest clauses where appropriate. Unusual disinheritance decisions should be discussed with the drafting attorney, whose file may later be the best defense.

Sources: EPTL 3-2.1, execution and attestation of wills (New York State Senate); Will (Cornell Law Institute)

How often should an estate plan be updated?

Review it on every major life event and at least every few years in between. Marriage, divorce (which revokes provisions for a former spouse by statute, though beneficiary forms must still be changed by hand), births and deaths in the family, a child’s marriage or divorce, significant changes in assets or in the tax law, including the federal exemption’s legislated changes, and a move to or from New York all call for a fresh look.

The review that matters most is the asset alignment check: beneficiary designations on retirement accounts and insurance, joint titles, and transfer-on-death registrations override the will wherever they conflict, and they drift out of sync silently over decades. Most ‘broken’ estate plans we see are not badly drafted; they are well-drafted plans whose beneficiary forms were never updated. A short review meeting prevents the most common probate disasters we litigate.

Sources: Will (Cornell Law Institute); Intestacy (Cornell Law Institute)

Sources

Frequently Asked Question Videos

Estate Planning Isn’t Just for the Wealthy | Angiuli & Gentile, LLP
Estate Planning Isn’t Just for the Wealthy | Angiuli & Gentile, LLP

Video Transcript

Whether or not an individual needs estate planning really has little to do with the amount of wealth that the individual has. This is because estate planning includes things such as having a power of attorney in place and having a health care proxy and living will in place. These documents are going to help individuals during their lifetimes. And in the event that we become unable to take care of our own affairs, it’s so critical to have legally designated who we want to stand in our shoes to do all of the things that we would otherwise be able to do. Because the alternative to that in certain situations is that a court could appoint a legal guardian for the individual where the legal guardian may be someone the individual doesn’t even know. As opposed to a friend or family member who could be designated had the individual done at least some basic estate planning such as doing a power of attorney and healthcare proxy.

Keep Your Estate Plan Up to Date | Angiuli & Gentile, LLP
Keep Your Estate Plan Up to Date | Angiuli & Gentile, LLP

Video Transcript

When clients come into the office, I encourage them to never hesitate to contact us if they have any questions, even after we’re done preparing all of their documents because I’d much prefer that they call or come in when they’re contemplating taking certain steps to make sure that they’re not going to negatively impact the estate planning that they had done as opposed to just winging it. We here send out letters to our estate planning clients typically every 2 to 3 years where we invite them to come in just to allow us to inform them of changes in the law and we also encourage them to come in to tell us about changes in their lives so that we can take a look to see whether any modifications need to be done to their existing estate plans or whether we should be doing new documents or addition additional documents. We also here at Angiuli & Gentile have a consultation policy where our existing estate planning clients, even when we’re done with doing our actual work, can come in at no cost to just ask their questions or to review their documents at any time.

Load More

Most People Wait
Too Long to Plan

24%

Only 24% of Americans have a will in 2025

146,396

New York Surrogate’s Courts recorded approximately 146,396 total filings in 2022

15.4%

Administration proceedings accounted for approximately 15.4% of New York Surrogate’s Court filings in 2022