What to Do If the Other Parent Denies Court-Ordered Parenting Time
If the other parent repeatedly denies your court-ordered parenting time, document each incident and consider asking the court to enforce the order. Depending on the facts, a judge may order make-up time, clarify the schedule, impose sanctions, or modify the custody arrangement.
Do not respond by taking the child outside your scheduled time, starting a confrontation, or stopping child support on your own. Those steps can create additional legal problems and distract from the other parent’s conduct.
This article explains New York law as of September 8, 2026. Your options will depend on the exact wording of your order and the history of your case.
Angiuli & Gentile
Family law legal help
Angiuli & Gentile can explain how family law may affect your rights, finances, and next steps.
Call now
718-550-0466Contact the firm
Start With the Exact Language of Your Parenting-Time Order
Before alleging a violation, read the full custody and parenting-time order. Check the provisions addressing:
- Pickup and return times
- Transportation responsibilities
- Holidays, school breaks, and vacations
- Required advance notice
- Illnesses and schedule changes
- Telephone or video contact
- Make-up parenting time
- The location of exchanges
A misunderstanding is different from knowingly disobeying a clear court order. For civil contempt, New York courts look for a lawful order containing a clear mandate, knowledge of that order, disobedience, and resulting prejudice to the other parent’s rights. The violation must be established by clear and convincing evidence. New York’s civil contempt statute applies in Family Court through Family Court Act § 156.
If your order says only that parenting time will occur “as agreed,” enforcement can be difficult when the parents cannot agree. You may need a modification that replaces vague language with specific days, times, transportation duties, and exchange procedures.
What to Do Each Time Court-Ordered Parenting Time Is Denied
Your response should create a reliable record without escalating the conflict.
First, be ready and on time for the exchange unless doing so would be unsafe. If the other parent has already said the visit will not happen, send a brief written message confirming that you remain available to follow the order. Do not enter the other parent’s home, make threats, or argue in front of the child.
A useful message might say:
The order provides that my parenting time begins today at 6:00 p.m. I am available to pick up our child as ordered. If you are refusing the exchange, please confirm that in writing. I am also requesting make-up time next weekend.
Keep the message factual. Avoid accusations about motives or lengthy discussions of past conflicts.
For every denied visit, record:
- The date and scheduled hours
- The exchange location
- When you arrived and how long you waited
- What the other parent said or did
- Whether the child was produced for the exchange
- The names of any witnesses
- Your written request for make-up time
- Any response you received
Save texts, emails, messages from co-parenting applications, relevant school or daycare records, and other documents that confirm what occurred. Preserve the original messages rather than relying only on screenshots.
Specificity matters. In Matter of Marisol Y. v. Steven Z., a New York appellate court affirmed the dismissal of a violation petition because broad allegations covering approximately two years did not identify particular events clearly enough. A strong petition identifies the dates, the violated provision, and the conduct involved.
How to Enforce a Parenting-Time Order in Staten Island
New York Courts provides Form GF-41, the Petition for Enforcement of an Order of Custody or Visitation. This petition asks Family Court to act when an existing order is not being followed.
For Staten Island families, custody and parenting-time proceedings are heard in Richmond County Family Court. The appropriate filing route can depend on whether the order came from Family Court, was incorporated into a divorce judgment, or remains connected to an active matrimonial case in Richmond County Supreme Court.
An enforcement petition should ordinarily identify:
- The court and date of the existing order
- The exact provision the other parent violated
- Each specific denied or interrupted visit
- Facts showing that the other parent knew about the order
- How the conduct deprived you of parenting time
- The relief you want the court to consider
The court will not automatically accept one parent’s account. Both sides may present testimony and evidence, and the judge will consider credibility, the order’s wording, the child’s circumstances, and any claimed justification for the missed time.
What Can a Judge Do About Repeatedly Denied Parenting Time?
New York Courts explains that, after a hearing, a judge may change the order or impose sanctions when a parent has failed to obey a custody or visitation order.
The available response depends on what will protect the child’s best interests and make the order workable. A judge may:
- Direct both parents to comply with the existing schedule
- Award make-up parenting time
- Set more precise pickup and return procedures
- Require communication through a co-parenting application
- Order exchanges at a neutral or monitored location
- Find a parent in civil contempt when the legal standard is met
- Modify custody or parenting time when circumstances justify it
Make-up time is a practical remedy, not merely an informal favor. In Matter of Nelson UU. v. Carmen VV., the appellate court upheld an award of a commensurate period of make-up parenting time.
When enforcement concerns an order entered in a divorce or matrimonial case, the court also has discretion to award counsel fees under Domestic Relations Law § 238. A fee award is not automatic.
Can Repeated Interference Lead to a Custody Modification?
Repeated, intentional interference can support a request to modify custody, but a custody change is never an automatic punishment.
The parent requesting modification must first show that circumstances have changed since the prior order. The court then decides whether a new arrangement would serve the child’s best interests. Relevant concerns include each parent’s ability to support the child’s relationship with the other parent, the child’s needs, stability, safety, and the overall history of the case.
The 2026 Second Department decision in Matter of Ghokassian v. Portala-Ghokassian illustrates how fact-specific this analysis can be. Although the record included conduct that interfered with the parent-child relationship, the court considered the children’s ages, wishes, existing relationships, therapeutic efforts, and overall welfare before deciding custody and parenting time.
A parent facing ongoing interference may file for enforcement, seek a modification, or request both forms of relief when supported by the facts. Angiuli & Gentile’s custody modification practice addresses changes involving violations of existing parenting plans.
What If the Other Parent Gives a Reason for the Denial?
A claimed reason does not necessarily excuse violating an order. The court will examine the facts.
If the other parent says the child was sick, relevant evidence may include medical records, school attendance, when you were notified, and whether the order addresses illness or make-up time. A genuine emergency is different from repeatedly using minor illnesses as a reason to cancel visits.
If the other parent says the child refuses to go, the child’s age, maturity, reasons, and each parent’s efforts to support the relationship may matter. Older children’s views can carry substantial weight, but a parent should not simply encourage refusal or treat the court’s schedule as optional.
Safety concerns require particular care. Domestic Relations Law § 240 protects good-faith, fact-supported actions taken lawfully to protect a child from abuse, neglect, or domestic violence. At the same time, a parent who believes the existing schedule has become unsafe should seek emergency court relief rather than indefinitely rewriting the order without judicial approval.
If a child is in immediate danger, call 911. Suspected child abuse or neglect can be reported through the channels identified by the New York Courts enforcement program.
Keep the Case Focused on Your Child and the Order
Being denied time with your child can feel deeply personal. In court, however, the most effective presentation is usually calm and specific.
Bring the order, a chronological incident log, complete communications, proof that you appeared for exchanges, and documents that address any explanations offered by the other parent. Show that you followed the order, requested reasonable make-up time, and tried to keep the child out of the conflict.
Avoid hostile social media posts, repeated confrontational messages, or involving the child in collecting evidence. The goal is not to create the largest possible file. It is to give the court a clear account of what happened and what practical order would protect the child’s relationship with both parents.
Why Contact Angiuli & Gentile About Denied Parenting Time?
Angiuli & Gentile’s family law attorneys represent Staten Island parents in custody disputes, parenting-time enforcement proceedings, and requests to modify existing orders. The firm’s services include reviewing parenting plans, gathering and presenting evidence, filing enforcement or modification applications, negotiating workable solutions, and representing parents in court.
A lawyer can help you decide whether your situation calls for enforcement, clearer terms, make-up time, contempt relief, or a broader custody modification. If the other parent keeps preventing your court-ordered time, contact Angiuli & Gentile to discuss the order, the documented violations, and a focused plan for moving forward.
Angiuli & Gentile
Family law legal help
Angiuli & Gentile can explain how family law may affect your rights, finances, and next steps.
Call now
718-550-0466Contact the firm
Staten Island Parenting-Time Enforcement FAQs
These answers provide general information. The wording of the order, the child’s circumstances, the court that issued the order, and the available evidence can change the analysis.
How many denied visits do I need before I can file an enforcement petition?
There is no fixed number of denied visits required before filing. One clearly documented, willful violation may justify an enforcement petition, while several poorly documented disagreements may not establish that the order was knowingly disobeyed.
The important details are the order’s exact language, the date and circumstances of the denial, the other parent’s knowledge, and the resulting loss of parenting time. Repetition can show a pattern, but your petition should describe individual incidents rather than making only a general claim that visits are “always” denied.
Sources: New York Courts Custody and Visitation Forms; Matter of Marisol Y. v. Steven Z.
Can the court give me make-up parenting time?
Yes. A New York court can award make-up parenting time to replace days or overnights that the other parent improperly withheld. The amount and scheduling of that time remain within the judge’s discretion and must be consistent with the child’s best interests.
Ask for specific, workable relief. For example, identify the number of missed days and propose dates that do not disrupt school or important activities. A judge may award equivalent time, direct the parents to select replacement dates, or combine make-up time with clearer exchange provisions.
Sources: Matter of Nelson UU. v. Carmen VV.; New York Courts FAQ on Interference With Custody or Visitation
Can the other parent be held in contempt for denying parenting time?
Yes, if the evidence meets New York’s civil contempt standard. You must establish by clear and convincing evidence that a lawful and unequivocal order existed, the other parent knew its terms, the order was disobeyed, and the conduct prejudiced your parenting-time rights.
Contempt is not automatic whenever a visit is missed. Ambiguous order language, a genuine emergency, a lack of proof, or circumstances beyond the parent’s control may affect the result. Courts can also choose less severe remedies, including make-up time, clarification, or modification.
Sources: New York Judiciary Law § 753; Family Court Act § 156; Matter of Kellezi v. Kellezi
What happens if my child refuses to attend parenting time?
A child’s refusal does not automatically prove that the other parent violated the order. The court may consider the child’s age, maturity, reasons for refusing, the parents’ conduct, and whether the custodial parent reasonably encouraged and facilitated the scheduled contact.
Do not physically force a distressed child into a vehicle or create a confrontation at the exchange. Document what occurred and request court intervention. Depending on the facts, the judge may maintain the schedule, order therapeutic parenting time, revise the arrangement, or find insufficient proof of a willful violation.
Sources: Matter of Ghokassian v. Portala-Ghokassian; New York Courts Visitation Information
Can the other parent cancel parenting time because my child is sick?
An illness does not automatically cancel court-ordered parenting time. The answer depends on the illness, the child’s needs, the order’s language, medical advice, and whether the parent acted reasonably rather than using illness as a pretext.
Ask for prompt information about the child’s condition and propose make-up time without turning the exchange into an argument. Preserve messages, medical information you are entitled to receive, and school or daycare attendance records. If illnesses repeatedly produce disputed cancellations, request a clearer provision addressing notice, documentation, and replacement time.
Sources: Domestic Relations Law § 240; ES v. NS
Can I stop paying child support if I am being denied parenting time?
No. Do not stop paying court-ordered child support on your own. The support order remains effective unless a court changes it, and unpaid amounts can become enforceable arrears even while the other parent is interfering with parenting time.
New York law permits limited court-ordered financial relief in some extreme interference cases, but the rules are narrow and fact-specific. Child support arrears generally cannot be canceled merely because visits were denied. Continue complying with the existing order while seeking enforcement or any requested modification through the court.
Sources: Domestic Relations Law § 241; Matter of Johnson v. Gordon; New York Courts Child Support Information
Should I call the police when the other parent refuses an exchange?
Call 911 if the child or another person is in immediate danger. For a routine parenting-time dispute, law enforcement involvement may create a record, but it does not replace an enforcement petition or guarantee that officers will transfer the child at the scene.
Remain calm and follow any instructions in the order concerning exchanges or law enforcement. If exchanges repeatedly become hostile, ask the court to require a neutral location, a police-precinct exchange, or a monitored exchange. Do not repeatedly involve police merely to pressure the other parent or frighten the child.
Sources: New York Courts Types of Visitation; New York Courts Custody and Visitation Enforcement Program
Can I file a parenting-time enforcement petition without a lawyer?
Yes. New York Courts offers a free DIY program for eligible parents whose New York custody or visitation orders are not being followed. The program helps prepare the petition to be filed in Family Court and identifies the information you will need.
Representing yourself remains different from receiving legal advice. A lawyer can evaluate whether the order is enforceable as written, identify useful evidence, draft specific allegations, respond to defenses, and determine whether you should seek enforcement, contempt, modification, or emergency relief.
Sources: Custody and Visitation Enforcement Petition DIY Program; New York Courts Custody and Visitation Orders
Can repeated parenting-time interference cause the other parent to lose custody?
It can contribute to a custody change, but interference does not produce an automatic transfer. The court must determine that circumstances have changed and that modifying custody would serve the child’s best interests after considering the entire family situation.
Evidence that a parent deliberately undermined the child’s relationship with the other parent can be significant. The judge will also consider stability, caregiving history, safety, the child’s needs and relationships, and age-appropriate preferences. Enforcement sanctions or a revised schedule may be chosen instead of changing residential custody.
Sources: Domestic Relations Law § 240; Matter of Ghokassian v. Portala-Ghokassian; New York Courts Custody and Visitation Overview
What if my parenting-time order was issued in another state?
An out-of-state custody or parenting-time order can often be registered and enforced in New York under the Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act. Registration allows a qualifying order to be enforced in the same manner as a New York custody determination.
Interstate cases involve additional jurisdiction, notice, and filing requirements. You may need a certified copy of the order and information about later proceedings or modifications. New York Courts provides separate UCCJEA forms for registering, enforcing, and, where jurisdiction permits, modifying out-of-state orders.
Sources: Domestic Relations Law § 77-d; New York Courts UCCJEA Forms
Sources
- New York Courts Custody and Visitation Forms
- New York Courts Custody and Visitation Enforcement Petition Program
- New York Courts FAQ on Interference With Custody or Visitation
- Richmond County Family Court
- New York Domestic Relations Law § 240
- New York Domestic Relations Law § 238
- New York Domestic Relations Law § 241
- New York Family Court Act § 156
- New York Judiciary Law § 753
- Matter of Marisol Y. v. Steven Z.
- Matter of Ghokassian v. Portala-Ghokassian
- Matter of Nelson UU. v. Carmen VV.
- New York Courts UCCJEA Forms
Angiuli & Gentile
Family law legal help
Angiuli & Gentile can explain how family law may affect your rights, finances, and next steps.
Call now
718-550-0466Contact the firm
